McAlester News-Capital, McAlester, OK

Local Sports

July 8, 2014

The two fronts of the NCAA-players war

McALESTER — Two fronts are currently being fought between the National Collegiate Athletic Association and its current and former players. In California, post-trial briefs were filed Wednesday for O’Bannon vs. NCAA, a class action lawsuit that argues players are entitled to profits from commercial uses of their images, most notably in video games.

In Illinois, Northwestern University football players were awarded the right to unionize as school employees in March. But six Republican congressmen and senators on Thursday requested a reversal of that ruling from a federal labor board.

Given the NCAA’s totalitarian refusal to acknowledge the differences between its players and non-athletes, the Wildcats’ solution of unionization makes sense. If being “student-athletes,” as the NCAA incessantly calls its workhorses, means making an organization billions of dollars but not being entitled to anything more than a college degree (if they’re lucky), why not try to get re-categorized as school employees?

But the Wildcats’ approach seeks compensation from individual schools instead of the NCAA itself, and therein lies a problem.

Texas, Wisconsin, Alabama and Michigan are all Division I universities which last year made more than $140 million in athletic revenue (Texas led with almost $166 million), according to data available on But schools like Georgia, Michigan State and Kentucky didn’t even crack $100 million, and Delaware, San Diego State and New Mexico State didn’t even crack $40 million.

Twenty-nine Division I schools didn’t even make $10 million.

The smaller an individual school’s athletics revenue, the less it can compensate its players, further unbalancing the national recruiting landscape. While that’s great if you’re a Florida Gators or Oklahoma Sooners fan ($130 and $123 million in revenue last year, respectively), any chance of a New Mexico or Boise State team winning a national football or basketball championship goes out the window.

Elite players already drift towards programs with a history of success or those who’ve turned out multiple professional players. That shouldn’t change, as winning a championship or playing in the NBA or NFL are great reasons to choose one school over another.

Reasons like regional familiarity and a chance to star on a less-talented team, on the other hand, have always ensured that at least a few of the best go to schools like Memphis, Florida-International and Akron. But if the Southern Louisiana ($10.9 million) school suddenly found itself having to match a probably much larger deal from Louisiana State ($117 million), the Jaguars would have no choice but to watch their last hopes go play for the Tigers.

Unionization isn’t the answer, even if NCAA players resemble employees more than they do students. Students, after all, can take whatever classes they want, whereas athletes — as has been shown repeatedly, including in Sports Illustrated’s September article on Oklahoma State — usually can only take classes that don’t interfere with practices and team activities.

Students can work, while athletes can’t. Students can take full advantage of collegiate opportunities such as studying abroad, and as O’Bannon players attorney Bill Isaacson argued, athletes really can’t.

If the NCAA calls its workforce “student-athletes” to emphasize that education comes first, it’s lying. At best, these players are “athlete-students,” and more likely they’re just “athletes.”

So what’s a fair compromise for these athletes who don’t actually get to experience the colleges to which they earn scholarships?

The first step might be to streamline or eliminate many of the NCAA’s draconian rules about player payoffs. If a football player wants to sell an autographed jersey for a tattoo, let him. If a volleyball player can get $500 or $1,000 or even more for an autograph session, let her.

No one is hurt in those situations. And if the NCAA’s rules were simpler, schools wouldn’t have to pay compliance officers to ensure everything’s legal, and that money could go back to the students.

That first step would be easy to implement. But this second step, offering NCAA “stock options,” might take longer.

Many corporations offer their employees stock options. This makes the employees work harder to make the company money, because that in turn means the employees’ stock becomes more valuable.

The NCAA could create a similar system in which players receive shares of the association’s annual profits. Athletes in the money-making sports like football and basketball would get more, and those in non-revenue sports like swimming and wrestling would get fewer.

For each year a player stays in school, he or she would get more stock options. Graduation would mean a bonus, and stock options wouldn’t vest until the player leaves the school for good.

This would create added incentives for players to stay in school and earn their degrees instead of bolting as soon as they’re draft-eligible.

Some athletes would benefit more than others in this system. But like it or not, in every industry some people just have more profitable and marketable skills.

And given the lack of professional options available to swimmers, cross country runners and field hockey players, anyone who earns a college scholarship in a non-revenue sport and doesn’t get a degree is a fool.

Millionaire student-athletes might further divide them from the rest of the student body, so simply dividing up the NCAA’s television and video game revenue isn’t the solution. Neither is the Northwestern players’ union.

But the NCAA doesn’t just refuse to come up with a solution — it seems incapable of acknowledging there’s a problem.

Until the NCAA stops denying the situation and helps come up with a fair solution, athletes will have no option but bad solutions like the one at Northwestern.

Contact Matt Goisman at

Text Only | Photo Reprints
Local Sports
  • Megan Jernigen and Taylor Jones Lady Hornets edge Lady Buffs

    Megan Jernigen’s two-run inside-the-park home run gave the Stuart Lady Hornets the only lead they’d need, eventually beating the McAlester Lady Buffaloes 3-1 Thursday at the Pittsburg County Softball Complex in McAlester.

    July 25, 2014 5 Photos

  • Lindy Morgan EOSC names Morgan new cheer coach

    Eastern Oklahoma State College has selected Lindy Morgan of Wilburton to lead the college’s new co-educational competitive cheerleading program.

    July 25, 2014 1 Photo

  • Disc golf takes local overseas

    Local disc golfer Matt House shot a five-over 197 for the first three rounds, missed the cut for the finals and finished tied for 84th in the Professional Disc Golf Association’s European Masters tournament July 17-20 in Stockholm, Sweden.

    July 25, 2014

  • Softball Complex Maintenance Crew 1 Softball Complex field crews hard at work

    Rain has been an ongoing issue for softball leagues this summer, but Pittsburg County Softball Complex director Randy Norman and his crew have done everything they can to drain the fields and hold games four nights a week.

    July 24, 2014 2 Photos

  • The Earthtones take stage tonight

    Tonight, McAlester will have an opportunity to enjoy some new age folk music at Rotary Park at the amphitheater.

    July 24, 2014

  • WSL returning to McAlester

    The World Softball League so enjoyed its “Bash for Bats” tournament July 12 at the Pittsburg County Softball Complex in McAlester that it’s decided to come back for the WSL Jersey Showdown Softball Tourney on Aug. 30 at the Softball Complex.

    July 24, 2014

  • Casey Fernandez 1 Ex-Buff Fernandez reaches golf semifinal

    Casey Fernandez, a senior at the University of Southern Mississippi and former golfer for the McAlester Buffaloes, made it all the way to the Oklahoma Golf Association’s State Amateur Championship semifinals before losing to Tulsa-Jenks golfer Preston Crawford on Wednesday at The Patriot Golf Course in Owasso.

    July 23, 2014 2 Photos

  • Maceo Thomas 1 Thomas key to McAlester disc golf growth

    For Maceo Thomas, one of the founding members of the Eagle Hill Disc Golf Club, the 12 golfers who came out for Saturday's mini-tournament in Krebs is a welcome sign of how much disc golf has grown since the club formed in 2011.

    July 22, 2014 2 Photos

  • Josh Ramsey Ramsey wins Eagle Hill tourney

    Josh Ramsey threw 10 birdies and eight pars, needing just 44 total strokes to win Saturday’s mini-tournament at Eagle Hill Disc Golf Course in Krebs.

    July 21, 2014 5 Photos

  • Bill Williams Williams looks back on Hartshorne coaching era

    Still living in Hartshorne six weeks after accepting a coaching job at Elk City, Williams sat down with the McAlester News-Capital to look back on his seven-year Hartshorne coaching career.

    July 20, 2014 1 Photo


Do you agree with the Supreme Court's Hobby Lobby decision?

     View Results
AP Video
Raw: Massive Dust Storm Covers Phoenix 12-hour Cease-fire in Gaza Fighting Begins Raw: Bolivian Dancers Attempt to Break Record Raw: Israel, Palestine Supporters Rally in US Raw: Palestinians and Israeli Soldiers Clash Raw: Air Algerie Flight 5017 Wreckage Virginia Governor Tours Tornado Aftermath Judge Faces Heat Over Offer to Help Migrant Kids Kerry: No Deal Yet on 7-Day Gaza Truce Kangaroo Goes Missing in Oklahoma More M17 Bodies Return, Sanctions on Russia Grow Gaza Residents Mourn Dead Amid Airstrikes Raw: Deadly Tornado Hits Virginia Campground Ohio State Marching Band Chief Fired After Probe Raw: Big Rig Stuck in Illinois Swamp Cumberbatch Brings 'Penguins' to Comic-Con Raw: Air Algerie Crash Site in Mali Power to Be Restored After Wash. Wildfire Crashed Air Algerie Plane Found in Mali Israel Mulls Ceasefire Amid Gaza Offensive
NDN Video
Big Weekend For Atlanta Braves In Cooperstown - @TheBuzzeronFox Chapter Two: Becoming a first-time director What's Got Jack Black Freaking Out at Comic-Con? Doctors Remove 232 Teeth From Teen's Mouth Bradley Cooper Explains His Voice in 'Guardians of the Galaxy' Deja vu: Another NYPD officer choke-holding a suspect 'Fifty Shades of Grey': Watch the Super Sexy First Trailer Now! Reports: Ravens RB Ray Rice Suspended For 1st 2 Games Of The Season Air Algerie plane with 119 on board missing over Mali Diamond Stone, Malik Newman, Josh Jackson and others showcase talent Free Arturo - The World's Saddest Polar Bear A Look Back at Batman On Film Through The Years LeBron James -- Dropped $2k On Cupcake Apology ... Proceeds To Benefit Charity Snoop Dogg Says He Smoked Weed at the White House Raw: Fight Breaks Out in Ukraine Parliament Chris Pratt Interrupts Interview To French Braid Intern's Hair Shirtless Super Mario Balotelli Dances While Ironing - @TheBuzzeronFOX Whoa! Watch "Housewives" Star Do the Unthinkable LeBron apologizes to neighbors with cupcakes Justin Bieber In Calvin Klein Underwear Shoot

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.